Turkish Lira: Liquidity Challenges Ahead

Declining volumes in currency trading has been an overriding theme as banks have been subject to stricter regulations on their trading activities. It is early to talk about the recent Trumpflation trade has caused any change globally, but when it comes to trading Turkish lira we still see that shrinking volume is an underlying trend.

Below we present the chart that shows total annual TRY trading volumes in form of forwards, spot trading and swaps.

try-trade-volume-forwardspot-swaps

Clearly 2013 was a turning point when uncertainties around emerging economies started to loom, leading stronger corporate demand for forwards to the end that hedge their FX risks. That period also marked the banks losing interest in TRY spot market. More importantly, we saw a huge drop in swap volume which is consistent with our voluntary deleveraging theory which simply based on Turkish banks’ weaker demand for foreign financing given the extremely high loans-to-deposits ratio (In Turkey banks have increased their foreign borrowings to finance the lending growth due to weakness in deposits, used swaps to hedge those positions). We believe that this credit positive, growth negative.

We note that spot trading volume of TRY declining roughly 14% y/y is worrisome that the currency is now more exposed to liquidity risk. As reported in some media outlets, global investment banks are now kind of through with TRY market. We expect TRY to remain volatile for some time come, which could partly offset by rate hike by the central bank. Our prospect is for a 2017E 10% policy rate and we recommend investors to consider 1-year xccy swaps afterwards.

The Revival Of “Hyperinflated” Turkish Lira

Inflation targeting is a successfully pursued monetary policy in countries who suffered high inflation for years such Zimbabwe. Turkey also set a new policy framework in purpose to lower the inflation and stabilize the currency rates. Under normal circumstances interest rates are expected to raised by the central bank provided that Turkey is an economy with a huge current account deficit and increasing inflation rate. Rising rates will both make Turkish lira more attractive to carry trade funds to finance the deficit and restrain the household demand that causes high inflation.

However what we recently have seen in Turkey is the politicians arguing against the independence of the central bank, like the ones Zimbabwe who paved the way for the central bank issuing 250 trillion notes. Moreover our politicians are also generating some economics theory that claims high rates cause high inflation. This sounds like tales from the newer-abnormal.

Meanwhile the inflation numbers came out this morning showing that inflation has not lost its momentum yet, contrary to expectations. More terrifyingly everyone in Turkey is so sure that our central bank will recklessly cut the rates with the lower inflation expectations even if the numbers indicate the contrary.

Charts below are explaining.

Inflation Trends

Core Inflation

Governments ignore to learn and memories are short.